Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters Recipe

If you have ever wished you could capture the nostalgic joy of those iconic peanut butter sandwich cookies right at home, you are in for a treat with this recipe for Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters. This delightful rendition brings together all the rich, nutty flavors, the tender yet slightly crisp texture, and that perfectly creamy peanut butter filling, replicating the beloved classic with ingredients you know and trust. Whether for a cozy snack, a lunchbox surprise, or simply to satisfy peanut butter cravings, these cookies are lovingly made and irresistibly delicious.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Gathering simple pantry staples is all you need to whip up these Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters, and each ingredient plays a crucial role in creating the perfect balance of creamy, crunchy, sweet, and buttery flavors.

• 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened: Provides the base richness and tender crumb texture.
• 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter: Brings authentic peanut flavor and moistness to the cookie dough.
• 1/2 cup granulated sugar: Adds sweetness while aiding in creating a slight crispness on the cookie edges.
• 1/2 cup brown sugar: Deepens flavor with subtle caramel notes and keeps cookies chewy.
• 1 large egg: Binds ingredients and contributes to a soft, structured cookie.
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract: Enhances all other flavors with its warm, aromatic touch.
• 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour: Forms the structure and body of each cookie.
• 3/4 teaspoon baking soda: Offers lift and helps achieve a tender but cakey texture.
• 1/4 teaspoon salt: Balances the sweetness and highlights the peanut butter’s natural savoriness.
• 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter (for filling): Creates the luscious center spread for the sandwich cookies.
• 1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened (for filling): Adds creamy richness to the peanut butter filling.
• 1 cup powdered sugar: Sweetens and thickens the filling for a smooth finish.
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract (for filling): Provides an extra layer of flavor in the filling.
• 1–2 tablespoons milk (as needed for texture): Adjusts filling consistency to perfectly spreadable.

How to Make Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters

Step 1: Prepare the Oven and Baking Sheet

Begin by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C) to ensure a consistent baking temperature. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a silicone mat to prevent sticking and promote even baking—these simple preparations set the stage for perfect cookies.

Step 2: Cream the Butter, Peanut Butter, and Sugars

In a large bowl, beat together the softened butter, creamy peanut butter, granulated sugar, and brown sugar until the mixture is light, fluffy, and well combined. This step is key for a tender cookie with just the right sweet and nutty flavor harmony.

Step 3: Add Egg and Vanilla

Mix in the egg and vanilla extract thoroughly until fully incorporated. The egg adds moisture and structure, while the vanilla lifts all of the other flavors, making your cookies deeply satisfying.

Step 4: Combine Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, whisk together flour, baking soda, and salt to distribute everything evenly. Gradually blend these dry ingredients into the wet mixture, forming a soft, pliable cookie dough that is ready to shape.

Step 5: Shape the Cookies

Roll the dough into roughly 1-inch balls, gently shape them into ovals to mimic the classic Nutter Butter look, then press each with a fork to create a charming crosshatch pattern. Lightly sprinkle granulated sugar over the tops for extra sparkle and crunch.

Step 6: Bake and Cool

Bake for 8 to 10 minutes until the edges turn slightly golden but the centers remain soft. Allow the cookies to cool completely on a wire rack—this cooling step is crucial for assembling the sandwiches without melting the filling.

Step 7: Mix the Filling

Beat together the peanut butter and softened butter until smooth and creamy. Gradually add powdered sugar and vanilla extract, then add milk one tablespoon at a time until the filling achieves a spreadable consistency that’s perfect for sandwiching.

Step 8: Assemble the Sandwiches

Once the cookies are completely cool, spread or pipe the peanut butter filling generously onto the flat side of one cookie. Top with a second cookie, gently pressing together to create those classic Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters sandwiches everyone will adore.

How to Serve Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters

Garnishes

For an extra touch of charm, dust your Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters lightly with a sprinkle of powdered sugar or crushed peanuts for that delightful texture contrast. A drizzle of melted chocolate over the top can also elevate these cookies into a special treat.

Side Dishes

Pair these cookies with a cold glass of milk to perfectly balance their rich, peanut buttery flavor. They also complement a scoop of vanilla ice cream or a fresh fruit salad, creating a dessert experience that feels both comforting and indulgent.

Creative Ways to Present

Try arranging Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters on a decorative platter with a variety of nut butters for dipping or create a cookie sandwich tower for parties to impress guests. Wrapping them in parchment and tying with twine makes for a charming homemade gift that friends and family will cherish.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Keep your Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters fresh by storing them in an airtight container at room temperature. They remain soft yet firm enough to handle for up to a week, making them a perfect make-ahead snack or dessert.

Freezing

For longer storage, freeze the assembled cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet until solid, then transfer to a freezer-safe container or bag. Frozen Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters keep beautifully for up to 3 months and thaw quickly at room temperature.

Reheating

If you prefer a warm, melty filling, gently microwave the cookies for about 10 seconds or warm them in a low oven for a few minutes. Be careful not to overdo it, or the filling may become too soft and oozy.

FAQs

Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy for the dough?

Absolutely! Crunchy peanut butter will add delightful peanut bits throughout the dough, giving the cookie extra texture. Just be aware it may change the smoothness of the dough slightly but it’s a delicious variation.

How can I make these cookies gluten-free?

Substitute the all-purpose flour with a gluten-free baking blend that measures cup-for-cup. Keep the other ingredients the same, and you’ll have gluten-free Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters that taste just as amazing.

Is there a way to make the filling less sweet?

Yes! Simply reduce the amount of powdered sugar in the filling to your taste or add a pinch of salt to balance the sweetness, making the peanut butter flavor shine through more prominently.

Can I use natural peanut butter without added sugar or oils?

You can, but natural peanut butter tends to be thinner and oilier, which might affect both the dough’s consistency and the filling texture. You may need to adjust the amount of flour or powdered sugar accordingly to get the right balance.

How do I achieve the classic oval shape and pattern?

Rolling the dough balls slightly longer than round and then gently pressing each with a fork to create the crosshatch look is the trick. Don’t press too hard—just enough to leave an impression that bakes into the signature pattern.

Final Thoughts

Nothing beats the joy of biting into a freshly baked cookie that tastes just like your favorite childhood classic. These Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters are simple to make, full of peanut buttery goodness, and utterly shareable. So grab your mixing bowl, gather your ingredients, and bring a little cookie magic into your kitchen today—you won’t regret it one bit!

Print